Same Size, Different Price Per Square Foot: Home Age in 80905

Market Monday | Heatherstone Appraisal Group
We were recently working in 80905. Here is what the data told us.
According to elevateMLS closed sales over the past two years, single-family homes in 80905 built before 1940 sold for about 14% more per square foot than similar-size homes built between 1940 and 1979.
Among homes under 1,000 square feet, the pre-1940 group sold at a median of $388 per square foot, compared with $339 for homes built from 1940 to 1979. The gap was nearly identical in the 1,000 to 1,499 square foot range, at $317 against $277, even though the older homes in that range were slightly larger.
Comparing homes of all sizes across the zip code tells a different story. Homes built since 2000 in 80905 are more than twice the size of the older stock, and larger homes almost always sell for less per square foot. On that measure alone, the newer homes look less expensive. Comparing homes of similar size is what brings the difference between pre-1940 and mid-century homes into view.
The data shows the difference but does not explain it. Older homes in 80905 are concentrated in certain parts of the zip code, and location and lot characteristics may account for part of the gap alongside the age of the home.
For anyone pricing a home in 80905, whether for a sale, an estate, or a divorce, a single price-per-square-foot figure for the zip code can miss a difference of this size.
— Heatherstone Appraisal Group
Joe Demory, partner of Heatherstone Appraisal Group, serves on the elevateMLS board of directors.
©2026 REALTOR® Services Corp. All rights reserved. Based on information from the REALTOR® Services Corp ("RSC") for the period November 1, 2024 through October 31, 2026. RSC information may not reflect all real estate activity in the market and is provided as is without warranty or guaranty.

